Italian Affair Pizza

Discover Italian Affair Pizza in Sherman, TX, offering authentic New York-style pizza by the slice, stromboli, calzones, and sausage pizza with crispy crusts. Call ahead for easy takeout and enjoy large, delicious pizzas crafted fresh just for you.

Welcome to Italian Affair Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza

Located at 104 N Woods St in Sherman, Texas, Italian Affair Pizza brings a slice of New York to this small town. This pizza restaurant has become a local gem known for its authentic New York style pizza. The casual atmosphere invites you to enjoy a quick bite or a leisurely meal, making it family-friendly and ideal for groups.

People rave about the crispy crust and generous toppings.

The menu offers various options, including pizza by the slice, calzones, and scrumptious strombolis. Whether you’re hitting the lunch rush during work hours or seeking a late-night snack, Italian Affair Pizza has you covered. Prepare to indulge in greasy, cheesy goodness that satisfies cravings and warms the heart.

Italian Affair Pizza boasts a range of features that keep patrons coming back. The restaurant specializes in pizza by the slice, allowing for quick and satisfying meals suited for the on-the-go diner. With excellent call-ahead ordering options, customers can snag their favorite pies without the wait, especially during peak dinner hours on Fridays.

Popular choices include the sausage pizza and meatball subs, both of which have won loyal fans.

The menu contains 13 delicious plates, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Average prices hover around $11.85, providing great value for the generous portions offered. With an inviting atmosphere and reliable service, Italian Affair Pizza puts a delightful twist on the dining experience in Sherman.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

104 N Woods St, Sherman, TX 75090, United States

Phone

+1 903-893-2171

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza

Within Sherman, Italian Affair Pizza stands out as a beloved establishment frequented by locals and visitors alike. The promise of fresh, hot pizza makes it a perfect stop after a day of exploring nearby attractions. The classic New York style crust snaps perfectly under each topping, offering an authentic experience that transports diners to the bustling streets of NYC.

This restaurant caters to everyone’s taste buds. The diverse menu includes single and multi-topping slices, each boasting vibrant flavors. Diners often explore options beyond pizza, treating themselves to hearty subs and pepperoni rolls. There's a dedication to rich flavors and quality ingredients, ensuring each bite delivers satisfaction.

Visiting during off-peak hours can reveal just how favorable this spot is. Many find their favorite times to visit are Tuesdays post-lunchtime or Saturdays before the dinner rush, allowing for relaxed dining, without the hustle and bustle. Visitors note that Fridays at 6 PM see the restaurant packed at 100% capacity, so planning ahead is wise. The energetic vibe and familiar atmosphere continue to bolster the community spirit in Sherman, making it more than just a dining destination; it’s a neighborhood hangout.

The inviting charm of Italian Affair Pizza lies not only in its food but also in its ability to create memories. Whether shared with friends, family, or even solo, the experience is warm and friendly, embodying what community dining should be.

Italian Affair Pizza

Italian Affair Pizza features a welcoming, no-frills exterior, with bright signage that draws in pizza lovers from near and far. The restaurant invites patrons with an unmistakable aroma of baking dough and rich tomato sauce. A cozy outdoor seating area provides an opportunity to enjoy fresh pizza in the Texas air, ideal for enjoying the lively Sherman atmosphere.

The vibe inside matches the exterior, casual and friendly, offering a place where conversations flow as easily as the cheese drips from the pies. Local artwork adorns the walls, showcasing the community spirit and giving character to the dining space.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-8 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-8 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Italian affair best known as Italian AF is my favorite family own pizzeria. Been going to this place since I was a kid when it was in the midway mall. Would get this over any big corp pizza place

C
Chris O.

We travel a lot, and this is THE BEST pizza we've ever found! The crust is perfect, sauce tasty and they are not stingy with the cheese. We've never gotten just a slice though-always order our own and take the rest home. There isn't much ambiance to the place, but the pizza is wonderful and staff is kind. We'll miss this place!

E
Elizabeth L.

This Sherman, Texas staple for the best pizza , calzones , strambolis and much more has been in town since I was a teenager at Midway Mall where many of grew up going to the arcade to test our video game skills challenging others to Mortal Kombat followed by a victory slice from The Indian affair and 25 years later in its new location near downtown. Thanks for the memories.

N
Nate g.

This is our families go to pizza spot! We live in whitesboro and drive here to get pizza cause there is nothing like this around us! New York Style pizza and would highly recommend!

D
David W.

Only place in Sherman TX that I've found that serves a NY style pizza. The dough is great and prices are reasonable. The only issue i can say is that by the slice the pepperoni was not cooked enough to my preference. I'm definitely going to order a whole pie next time and I'll bet it will be spot on. I'll post again for that experience. Okay ordered a full pie and toppings were cooked to my liking. Also found out you can request how you'd like it cooked. The only negative I've have to say is their hours of operation. Gotta get that pizza craving taken care of.

B
Boogy T.

BEST PIZZA IN THE WHOLE ENTIRE WORLD HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This place is awesome. It has been awesome since it was in the Midway Mall. The staff is great. The pizza is to die for. I HIGHLY recommend checking this place out if you are in town. Absolutely amazing food and the price is awesome. Thank you guys.

E
Eric H.